Home › Pricing Clothes
How to price clothes at a garage sale
Clothing is the category people price worst, and it’s the category we watch not sell every single weekend. The problem is almost never the clothes. It’s the number on the tape.
The standard advice is to price used goods at a quarter to a third of retail. That works for a drill. It does not work for clothing, because the person standing in your driveway is not comparing your shirt to a new shirt — they’re comparing it to the rack at a thrift store two miles away where everything is $4 and someone else has already washed it.
So the honest starting point: at a garage sale, you are competing with thrift store pricing, and you lose on convenience. Price accordingly and things move. Price on sentiment and you’ll be folding it all back into totes on Saturday afternoon.
What clothing actually sells for
Ordinary adult clothing
$1–$3. T-shirts, ordinary jeans, tops, sweaters. A dollar moves things fast; three dollars is the ceiling before people start putting it back down.
Jackets, coats and outerwear
$5–$15. The one clothing category where people expect to pay real money. Carhartt, Levi’s and leather sit at the top of that range.
Boots and shoes
$5–$20. Condition drives this more than brand. Worn-through soles are worth nothing; good leather work boots are worth the top of the range.
Kids’ clothing
50¢–$1, or bundled. Never price kids’ clothes individually. A grocery bag for $5 sells; twenty items at a dollar each does not.
Five rules that matter more than the numbers
- Hang it, don’t pile it. A $12 folding rack and a box of hangers will out-earn anything else you spend money on. Clothing in a tote is clothing nobody touches.
- Price by the group, not the garment. “All shirts $2” on one big sign beats individual tags — less work for you, no negotiating, and people buy four instead of one.
- Round numbers only. $1, $2, $5. Nobody wants to make change for $1.75 at seven in the morning, including you.
- Discount on a schedule and say so. Full price Thursday, half price Saturday, fill-a-bag-for-$5 Saturday afternoon. Announce it and people come back.
- Have a bag price ready from the start. The last two hours of any sale are a bulk business. Decide the number before you’re tired.
What to pull out of the sale entirely
Some things are worth more than a garage sale can ever get for them, and putting them on a $2 table is how they end up gone for $2. Set these aside:
- Anything genuinely old
- Work boots with a maker’s stamp
- Leather dress shoes
- Leather jackets
- Harley-Davidson
- Carhartt
- Levi’s
- Ariat & Justin
- Red Wing
- Danner
- Patagonia
- The North Face
- Nike & Jordan
- Sitka & hunting gear
- Military issue
- Ralph Lauren
- Faded band or event tees
These sell for real money to the right buyer and almost nothing to a driveway crowd. A single pair of good boots can be worth more than everything else on your clothing table combined. Our full buying list is here — and it’s worth a look before you tag anything, because the pieces we pay most for are usually the ones people assume are worthless.
The mistake we see most: a beat-up old tee priced at 50¢ because it’s faded and thin. On genuinely old clothing, that wear is the value. If it looks beat up and it looks old, don’t put it on the dollar table — photograph it.
Two ways we can help with this
Before your sale, we pay $20 cash for a first look at the clothing and shoes — you keep the twenty whether we buy or not, and anything we buy is money you didn’t have to price, tag, or haggle over. After your sale, send photos of whatever’s left and we’ll usually take the clothing off your hands so it doesn’t go back in the garage.
Not sure what something’s worth?
Send a photo before you price it. We’ll tell you straight, and there’s no obligation either way.
Rather just text them? (928) 294-6488